by Thomas Lepeltier, Le Point, 26 November 2024
The collective Scientifiques en rébellion has published a short manifesto with Seuil, Sortir des labos pour défendre le vivant. The article welcomes these scientists’ willingness to take part in public debate, but criticises them for passing off vague political ideas as laboratory truths.
In brief
- It is commendable for scientists to step out of their laboratories to inform their fellow citizens: a discovery is never neutral for society, and the collective is right to say so.
- But its manifesto presents as scientific some vague formulas (‘defending the living world’) and a catastrophist picture: an ‘omnipresent’ deterioration in living conditions, pesticides that ‘poison’ the environment, life on Earth under threat.
- Science describes, it does not prescribe. By legitimising civil disobedience to impose degrowth, the collective seeks to bypass democratic deliberation.
The article’s three arguments
Words that do not help decide anything
Does defending ‘the living world’ mean also protecting the bacteria that cause meningitis, or the wolf that devours the lamb? Seeking to ‘preserve the entirety of our ecosystem’ would amount to condemning all human activity. This vagueness makes any duty towards the living world absurd.
A picture painted too dark
Some species are declining, others are proliferating, such as wild boar. Poverty is falling and life expectancy is rising. Pesticides help feed a humanity less and less afflicted by famine, and no study predicts the disappearance of life on Earth.
From science to authoritarianism
The collective claims to stick to scientific findings while deeming it ‘imperative to change our culture and our civilisations’. It legitimises civil disobedience and illegal actions to impose degrowth: this means coercing the government rather than convincing it.
‘Your doctor can warn you that if you keep drinking, you risk cirrhosis. But it is not their place to impose sobriety on you.’Thomas Lepeltier, Le Point, 26 November 2024
Why this debate matters to us
APALA approaches environmental issues on the basis of data, without catastrophism. This text points out that real problems (the decline of certain species, excessive pesticide use, global warming) justify neither sweeping generalisations nor the idea that a single societal choice could follow from science. It extends an earlier article by Thomas Lepeltier on the same collective, devoted to the confusion between knowledge and political decision-making. The discussion concerns the texts and actions of a collective, not individuals.
Questions for debate
- Defending ‘the living world’: what does this phrase actually help us decide?
- How can we talk about real environmental problems without falling into catastrophist generalisations?
- When scientists take a stand, how can we distinguish what stems from their knowledge from what stems from their opinions?
To go further on apala.fr
Summary written by Claude (Opus 5.5 model), an artificial intelligence, for APALA, based on the article published in Le Point on 26 November 2024. The views expressed are those of the author. Spotted an error? Write to us.








0 comments