Scientifiques en rébellion: from science to authoritarianism

by Thomas Lepeltier | 26 Nov 2024 | Our experts in the media, Methodology, Progress

Reading time is .

Key points

  • The manifesto: Sortir des labos pour défendre le vivant (Seuil), by the Scientifiques en rébellion collective, founded in 2020.
  • The vagueness: defending ‘the living world’ does not allow anything to be decided.
  • The facts: some species are declining, others are proliferating; poverty is falling and life expectancy is rising.
  • The conclusion: science describes; imposing degrowth through civil disobedience bypasses democracy.

🔬 Can scientists say, in the name of science, which society we should choose?

That is what the manifesto of the Scientifiques en rébellion collective, ‘Sortir des labos pour défendre le vivant’ (Seuil), claims. In Le Point, the essayist Thomas Lepeltier, a specialist in the history and philosophy of science, welcomes their wish to take part in public debate, but challenges its substance.

🧭 Three arguments
• The vagueness: does defending ‘the living world’ also mean protecting the bacteria that cause meningitis?
• The facts: some species are declining, others are proliferating; poverty is falling and life expectancy is rising.
• Democracy: legitimising civil disobedience to impose degrowth means coercing instead of convincing.

A critique that does not deny real problems (the decline of certain species, excessive pesticide use, global warming), but refuses to accept that a single societal choice follows from them in the name of science.

💬 ‘Your doctor can warn you that, if you keep drinking, you risk cirrhosis. But it is not their place to impose sobriety on you.’

👉 The summary of the article and the link to Le Point are below.

#science #democracy #publicdebate

🔬 Can scientists say, in the name of science, which society we should choose?

The Scientifiques en rébellion collective thinks so. In its manifesto ‘Sortir des labos pour défendre le vivant’ (Seuil), it calls for changing ‘our culture and our civilisations’, going as far as legitimising civil disobedience.

In Le Point, the essayist Thomas Lepeltier, a specialist in the history and philosophy of science, welcomes these researchers’ desire to take part in public debate. But he shows that their text passes off vague political ideas as laboratory truths.

🌿 A rallying cry that does not allow anything to be decided
Does defending ‘the living world’ also mean protecting the bacteria that cause meningitis, or the wolf that devours the lamb? Wanting to ‘preserve the entirety of our ecosystem’ would amount to condemning all human activity.

📊 A picture painted too dark
Some species are declining, others are proliferating, such as wild boar. Poverty is falling, life expectancy is rising, pesticides help feed a humanity less and less afflicted by famine, and no study predicts the disappearance of life on Earth.

🗳️ From science to authoritarianism
By legitimising illegal actions to impose degrowth, the collective seeks to coerce rather than convince. Yet science describes; deciding is a matter for democratic debate.

💬 His comparison sums up what is at stake: ‘Your doctor can warn you that if you keep drinking, you risk cirrhosis. But it is not their place to impose sobriety on you.’

Do scientists have a role to play in public debate, and how far should it go?

👉 The three arguments in detail, with the link to the Le Point article, are below.

#science #democracy #ecology #biodiversity #degrowth #publicdebate

🔬 Can science dictate society’s choices?

In Le Point, essayist Thomas Lepeltier, a specialist in the history and philosophy of science, responds to the manifesto ‘Sortir des labos pour défendre le vivant’.

1️⃣ Defending ‘the living world’ does not help decide anything: should we also protect the bacteria that cause meningitis?
2️⃣ The picture is painted too dark: some species are declining, others are proliferating, and life expectancy is rising.
3️⃣ Science describes, it does not prescribe: imposing degrowth through civil disobedience means coercing rather than convincing.

And you, where do you draw the line?

📎 Full summary and link to the article: link in bio.

#science #democracy #ecology #biodiversity #degrowth

by Thomas Lepeltier, Le Point, 26 November 2024

The collective Scientifiques en rébellion has published a short manifesto with Seuil, Sortir des labos pour défendre le vivant. The article welcomes these scientists’ willingness to take part in public debate, but criticises them for passing off vague political ideas as laboratory truths.

In brief

  • It is commendable for scientists to step out of their laboratories to inform their fellow citizens: a discovery is never neutral for society, and the collective is right to say so.
  • But its manifesto presents as scientific some vague formulas (‘defending the living world’) and a catastrophist picture: an ‘omnipresent’ deterioration in living conditions, pesticides that ‘poison’ the environment, life on Earth under threat.
  • Science describes, it does not prescribe. By legitimising civil disobedience to impose degrowth, the collective seeks to bypass democratic deliberation.

The article’s three arguments

1. Vagueness

Words that do not help decide anything

Does defending ‘the living world’ mean also protecting the bacteria that cause meningitis, or the wolf that devours the lamb? Seeking to ‘preserve the entirety of our ecosystem’ would amount to condemning all human activity. This vagueness makes any duty towards the living world absurd.

2. The facts

A picture painted too dark

Some species are declining, others are proliferating, such as wild boar. Poverty is falling and life expectancy is rising. Pesticides help feed a humanity less and less afflicted by famine, and no study predicts the disappearance of life on Earth.

3. Democracy

From science to authoritarianism

The collective claims to stick to scientific findings while deeming it ‘imperative to change our culture and our civilisations’. It legitimises civil disobedience and illegal actions to impose degrowth: this means coercing the government rather than convincing it.

In the European Union, the pesticide risk indicator fell by 59% between 2011 and 2024, mainly because banned substances are no longer sold. Quantities sold are falling much less, and not everywhere: in 2024, they were 36% below their 2011-2013 level in Italy, but 9% above it in France.
‘Your doctor can warn you that if you keep drinking, you risk cirrhosis. But it is not their place to impose sobriety on you.’Thomas Lepeltier, Le Point, 26 November 2024

Why this debate matters to us

APALA approaches environmental issues on the basis of data, without catastrophism. This text points out that real problems (the decline of certain species, excessive pesticide use, global warming) justify neither sweeping generalisations nor the idea that a single societal choice could follow from science. It extends an earlier article by Thomas Lepeltier on the same collective, devoted to the confusion between knowledge and political decision-making. The discussion concerns the texts and actions of a collective, not individuals.

Questions for debate

  1. Defending ‘the living world’: what does this phrase actually help us decide?
  2. How can we talk about real environmental problems without falling into catastrophist generalisations?
  3. When scientists take a stand, how can we distinguish what stems from their knowledge from what stems from their opinions?

To go further on apala.fr

Summary written by Claude (Opus 5.5 model), an artificial intelligence, for APALA, based on the article published in Le Point on 26 November 2024. The views expressed are those of the author. Spotted an error? Write to us.

Read the article in Le Point ↗︎

AI: is the apocalypse imminent?

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier looks back at the affair of the OpenAI agents that hacked Hugging Face: human negligence, not signs of an apocalypse. Our summary in three arguments.

Is the zombie chicken the future of the animal rights movement?

In L’Amorce, Thomas Lepeltier proposes reducing farmed animals’ capacity to suffer rather than waiting for the end of meat, going as far as imagining a “zombie chicken”. Our summary in three arguments.

What if the danger of AI were not that it exterminates us, but that it advises us too well?

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier presents Antoine Buéno’s ‘Guidance’: the danger of AI would be less that it exterminates us than that it advises us too well. Our summary in three arguments.

Is the world burning?

In Causeur, Thomas Lepeltier compares the exceptional wildfires of summer 2026 in France with global satellite data, which describe a rather quiet year. Our summary in three arguments.

Let’s have done with organic farming!

In Atlantico, Thomas Lepeltier challenges the founding principle of organic farming, the preference for the natural over the synthetic, and judges its record to be more nuanced than its image. Our summary in three arguments.

A future without suffering? A video to open the debate

With The Flares, APALA offers a short foresight video: what if reducing avoidable suffering, among humans and other animals alike, were one of the great undertakings of the century?

Tatiana Giraud: when biodiversity turns into a religion

In Causeur, Thomas Lepeltier criticised the way Tatiana Giraud presents biodiversity; she responded, and he replied. Our summary of the three texts: arguments, quotations and questions for debate.

The fanciful claims of biologist Olivier Hamant against performance

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier challenges the opposition between performance and robustness championed by the biologist Olivier Hamant: in his view, the resilience of societies comes from innovation and efficiency. Our summary in three arguments.

Organic: beware, toxic!

In Causeur, Thomas Lepeltier draws a lesson from Anses’s decision to withdraw copper fungicides: judge each product by its effects, not by its natural or synthetic origin. Our summary in three arguments.

Will artificial intelligence end up exterminating us?

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier examines the thesis of Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares that a superintelligent AI would exterminate humanity. Our summary in three arguments.

0 comments

make a donation!

Public-interest association: €10 for you means nearly €30 for us, after tax relief.

Understand how it works