Is the energy transition a fable?

by Thomas Lepeltier | 6 Nov 2026 | Our experts in the media, Resources, Progress

Reading time is .

Key points

  • The thesis under discussion: according to Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, energy sources add up without ever replacing one another.
  • The facts: in France, fossil fuel consumption has fallen by around 20% since the 1970s, while the economy kept growing.
  • The service provided: a heat pump supplies three to four times more heat than the electricity it consumes.
  • The conclusion: a transition that is too slow calls for speeding it up, not for degrowth.

🔎 The energy transition is supposedly a fable: no energy source has ever replaced another. This thesis of the historian Jean-Baptiste Fressoz has become widely accepted. France’s figures tell a different story.

In Le Point, the essayist Thomas Lepeltier, a specialist in the history and philosophy of science, challenges not so much this account of the past as what Fressoz infers from it for the future: yesterday’s societies were not trying to move away from fossil fuels, whereas policies aim to do so today.

🧭 Three arguments
• The facts: in France, the share of fossil fuels in electricity fell from 57% in 1975 to 11% fifteen years later, thanks to nuclear power, and fossil fuel consumption has fallen by around 20% since the 1970s, while the economy kept growing. The United Kingdom has almost eliminated coal from its electricity.
• The service provided: a heat pump supplies three to four times more heat than the electricity it consumes.
• The ‘generalised Jevons paradox’: a correlation is not a cause, and it does not prove that the transition is running up against a limit.

If the transition is too slow, we need to speed it up, not organise degrowth.

💬 ‘Fressoz thus counters a transition he deems improbable with a remedy that is at least as improbable.’

👉 The summary of the article and the link to Le Point are below.

#energytransition #energy #degrowth

🔎 No energy source has ever replaced another, and the energy transition is supposedly a fable. This idea, championed by the historian Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, has become widely accepted. Yet France’s example tells a different story.

According to Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, energy sources have always added up: coal did not drive out wood, nor oil coal, and wind turbines, solar panels and electric cars still depend on fossil fuels. His thesis is often used as an argument for degrowth.

In Le Point, the essayist Thomas Lepeltier, a specialist in the history and philosophy of science, challenges not so much this account of the past as what the historian infers from it for the future. For yesterday’s societies were not trying to move away from fossil fuels; today, policies aim to do so.

📊 Substitutions already observed
In France, the share of fossil fuels in electricity fell from 57% in 1975 to 11% fifteen years later, thanks to nuclear power. Since the 1970s, fossil fuel consumption has fallen by around 20%, and the economy has continued to grow. The United Kingdom has almost eliminated coal from its electricity.

💡 The service provided, not the quantity of energy
A heat pump manufactured using fossil fuels can eliminate a home’s gas consumption for twenty years. And it supplies three to four times more heat than the electricity it consumes: replacing fossil fuels therefore does not require as much low-carbon energy.

🧭 A correlation is not a cause
There is nothing puzzling about a more efficient global economy that emits more: it is growing faster than it is decarbonising. The ‘generalised Jevons paradox’ invoked by Fressoz does not prove that the transition is running up against a limit. If it is too slow, we need to speed it up, not organise degrowth.

💬 His conclusion turns the accusation around: ‘Fressoz thus counters a transition he deems improbable with a remedy that is at least as improbable.’

Should the transition be measured in quantities of energy or in services provided?

👉 The three arguments in detail, with the link to the Le Point article, are below.

#energytransition #energy #climate #nuclear #degrowth #progress

🔎 No energy source has supposedly ever replaced another: the energy transition is said to be a fable. The facts say otherwise.

In Le Point, the essayist Thomas Lepeltier, a specialist in the history and philosophy of science, responds to the historian Jean-Baptiste Fressoz.

1️⃣ Substitutions do happen: in France, fossil fuels went from 57% to 11% of electricity in fifteen years.
2️⃣ What matters is the service provided: a heat pump supplies three to four times more heat than the electricity it consumes.
3️⃣ The ‘generalised Jevons paradox’ does not prove that the transition is running up against a limit: if it is too slow, it should be sped up, not replaced by degrowth.

Speeding up the transition or shrinking the economy: which path seems more realistic to you?

📎 Full summary and link to the article: link in bio.

#energytransition #energy #nuclear #climate #degrowth

by Thomas Lepeltier, Le Point, 6 November 2026

For the historian Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, the energy transition is a fable: no energy source has ever replaced another. The article challenges not so much his account of the past as what he infers from it for the future, and turns the accusation around: the real fable is rather that of a necessary degrowth.

In brief

  • According to Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, energy sources have always added up without replacing one another: coal did not drive out wood, nor oil coal, and wind turbines, solar panels and electric cars still depend on fossil fuels.
  • But past societies were not trying to move away from fossil fuels. Today, policies aim to do so, and France and the United Kingdom alike show that an economy can reduce its fossil fuel use in absolute terms while continuing to grow.
  • His ‘generalised Jevons paradox’ does not prove that the transition is running up against a limit: if it is too slow, we need to speed it up, not organise degrowth.

The article’s three arguments

1. The facts

Substitutions already observed

In France, the share of fossil fuels in electricity fell from 57% in 1975 to 11% fifteen years later, thanks to nuclear power. Since the 1970s, coal consumption has been cut fivefold and fossil fuel consumption has fallen by around 20%, and the carbon footprint, including imports, has fallen by around 20% since 1990. The United Kingdom has almost eliminated coal from its electricity.

2. The service provided

Less energy for the same result

A heat pump manufactured using fossil fuels can eliminate a home’s gas consumption for twenty years: depending on fossil fuels to be manufactured is not the same as depending on them to operate. And since it supplies three to four times more heat than the electricity it consumes, replacing fossil fuels does not require as much low-carbon energy.

3. The Jevons paradox

A correlation is not a cause

There is nothing puzzling about the global economy becoming more efficient while emitting more: it is growing faster than it is decarbonising. Rebound effects can eat into energy savings, but not cancel them out. To justify imposing degrowth, one would have to prove that the transition is inherently bounded, which the paradox does not demonstrate.

Between 1995 and 2024, the wealth produced in the European Union rose by 60%, while its consumption of fossil fuels fell by 26% (−31% since its 2006 peak). In France, fossil fuels have fallen by a third since their 2005 peak, while GDP rose by 24%. This chart does not count the energy embodied in imported products.
“Fressoz thus counters a transition he considers unlikely with a remedy that is at least as unlikely.”Thomas Lepeltier, Le Point, 6 November 2026

Why this debate matters to us

Jean-Baptiste Fressoz is one of the most listened-to voices in the energy debate, and his thesis is often used as an argument for degrowth. APALA shares this analysis: the slowness of the transition is a challenge to be met through investment, innovation and regulation, not proof that it is impossible. The discussion concerns public theses, not the person.

One watt of solar panel cost 132 dollars in 1975 (in 2025 dollars); in 2025 it costs 0.12, more than a thousand times less. Since 2010 alone, the price has fallen twentyfold. Innovation and large-scale production are bringing down the cost of the transition. Source: Nemet (2009); Farmer and Lafond (2016); IRENA, Renewable Power Generation Costs in 2024 and in 2025 (prices since 2010). Chart from Our World in Data, in English; data subject to their producer’s terms.

Questions for debate

  1. When one country phases out coal and another consumes more of it, is the transition impossible, or does it simply need to be rolled out more widely?
  2. Should the transition be measured in quantities of energy or in services provided?
  3. If the transition is too slow, is it better to speed it up or to shrink the economy? Which of these paths is the more realistic?

To go further on apala.fr

Summary written by Claude (Opus 5.5 model), an artificial intelligence, for APALA, based on the article published in Le Point on 6 November 2026. The views expressed are those of the author. Found an error? Write to us.

Read the article in Le Point ↗︎

AI: is the apocalypse imminent?

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier looks back at the affair of the OpenAI agents that hacked Hugging Face: human negligence, not signs of an apocalypse. Our summary in three arguments.

Is the zombie chicken the future of the animal rights movement?

In L’Amorce, Thomas Lepeltier proposes reducing farmed animals’ capacity to suffer rather than waiting for the end of meat, going as far as imagining a “zombie chicken”. Our summary in three arguments.

What if the danger of AI were not that it exterminates us, but that it advises us too well?

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier presents Antoine Buéno’s ‘Guidance’: the danger of AI would be less that it exterminates us than that it advises us too well. Our summary in three arguments.

Is the world burning?

In Causeur, Thomas Lepeltier compares the exceptional wildfires of summer 2026 in France with global satellite data, which describe a rather quiet year. Our summary in three arguments.

Let’s have done with organic farming!

In Atlantico, Thomas Lepeltier challenges the founding principle of organic farming, the preference for the natural over the synthetic, and judges its record to be more nuanced than its image. Our summary in three arguments.

A future without suffering? A video to open the debate

With The Flares, APALA offers a short foresight video: what if reducing avoidable suffering, among humans and other animals alike, were one of the great undertakings of the century?

Tatiana Giraud: when biodiversity turns into a religion

In Causeur, Thomas Lepeltier criticised the way Tatiana Giraud presents biodiversity; she responded, and he replied. Our summary of the three texts: arguments, quotations and questions for debate.

The fanciful claims of biologist Olivier Hamant against performance

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier challenges the opposition between performance and robustness championed by the biologist Olivier Hamant: in his view, the resilience of societies comes from innovation and efficiency. Our summary in three arguments.

Organic: beware, toxic!

In Causeur, Thomas Lepeltier draws a lesson from Anses’s decision to withdraw copper fungicides: judge each product by its effects, not by its natural or synthetic origin. Our summary in three arguments.

Will artificial intelligence end up exterminating us?

In Le Point, Thomas Lepeltier examines the thesis of Eliezer Yudkowsky and Nate Soares that a superintelligent AI would exterminate humanity. Our summary in three arguments.

0 comments

make a donation!

Public-interest association: €10 for you means nearly €30 for us, after tax relief.

Understand how it works